In a state where sexual orientation is not a legally protected class, a pediatrician objects to treating an infant child with lesbian parents. She is concerned that her deeply held views about homosexuality will compromise her ability to give proper care that fully includes the parents.

Help the provider navigate this scenario using the I CARE Model.

What should the provider do first? *

Be honest with the parents about her objection.

Refuse to treat the child and transfer the baby to another provider in the practice.

Examine her own biases and consider to what extent the parents’ sexual orientation impacts the health of the patient.

What should the provider do next? *

Consult with her supervisor and the facility’s ethics committee (if there is one).

Refuse to treat the child and transfer the baby to another provider in the practice.

Accept the new patient, despite feeling conflicted about the quality of the care she will be able to provide to the child.

Register For This Site

Course: Navigating Conscience Objections in Health Care

Personal Conscience Case Study #1: ACTION